Willie parker or edgerrin james and why?

Question

im gonna trade on, i just don't know which one to trade

Answer 1

Trade James he doesnt have as good of a team and Willie has a way better line blocking for him

Answer 2

trade edgerrin james all the way..........willie parker is way better

last year parker was a way better running back as he was one of the leading rushers, this year he is going to be just as good if not better

however, edgerrin james is simply getting older and worse by the year

he is going to be in a heavy passing offense so he won't get the number of carries like parker, and he will split time with shipp and arrington (btw....shipp is going to be their goaline back, so he will score a lot of the touchdowns leaving less point for james)  

Answer 3

Parker seems to be getting worse every season.  He's still a solid back, but with Mendenhall playing great so far in the preseason, I would be a little concerned if he was on my team.  But Edgerrin isn't that great either.  However, the Cardinals have finally seemed to pull their offense together with Larry Fitz and Boldin and Leinhart, so that will take more pressure off James.  It's really a toss up between the two.  I would trade Parker, but it's hard to predict who's gonna be better out of these two.

Answer 4

Trade parker cuz mendenhall will make the tds cuz he is bigger.

Answer 5

I like Edge since he is an every down back while Parker will lose some carries, especially at the goal line, to Mendenhall.

P.S. - The poster above me is flat wrong.  Last year Edge had 184.6 fantasy points (1,426 yards from scrimmage and 7 TDs) compared to Parker's 160 fantasy points (1,480 yards but only 2 TDs) and with Mendenhall in the picture Parker is projected to do way less this year.

Answer 6

people are gonna kill me for it but i'm gonna say James.

Why?

Mendenhall.

The rookie's been looking good in the preseason, and will be getting a lot of touchdown carries.

James, on the other hand, is the featured back, and will be getting every red zone carry.

Trade Fast Willy.

Also, people will probably view Parker as a better back, so you'll get a better trade for him.