With four weeks left who wins this trade? I get Josh Beckett and JJ Hardy for Carpenter, Liriano and Tejada.?

Question

There are only 4 weeks left until my playoffs for fantasy. I was offered Josh Beckett and JJ Hardy for Carpenter, Liriano and Tejada.

My staff is:

Verlander

Johan Santana

Lee

Baker

Floyd

Nolasco

Pelfrey

Sherrill

Percival

Sean Marcum

Answer 1

Process of elimination.Carpenter will not be back healthy this year.Note I said healthy.I read an inside report that said if Carpenter does come back this year it wont be 100%.Liriano is tearing up the minors but his agent and the Twins are going at it.That leaves Tejada.A post steroid recovery child who is underperforming.I take Beckett who you are guaranteed wins and strikeouts(no gamble)and then you have Hardy who is hotter than a texans underwear at a chili cookout.

Answer 2

tejada> hardy.    i would not do that trade. u got so much upside with lirano and carpetner if they return good. i wouldnt not do it.  but what place r u in. is it a shawllow league?