Women: Was what these women did justified?

Question

A friend who studies such matters recently told me of an incident that happened several decades ago. A man, who had a history since adolescence of molesting, raping, and torturing little girls, was the focus of revenge by two sisters, one of whom had a 5 year old daughter who was repeatedly raped and tortured by the man.

In addition to other acts, the women covered his erect p***s with honey or cheese or something, and his p***s was then inserted into a cage of hungry rats. The rats then proceeded to slowly eat the man's p***s.

The man later confessed to the crimes. He eventually castrated himself (probably due to sexual frustration) and was then put into a mental institution where he spent the rest of his life.

I don't condone vigilante justice, nor do I think that such barbaric methods be incorporated into any justice system.

Obviously if I could find a link online to this case, I would definitely post it.

I simply want to know what other women think. Is this a fitting punishment for a man who raped and tortured several little girls?

Answer 1

i think that the issue of gender shouldn't come into it. either way i believe the man deserved to be locked up.

Answer 2

I don't think that it was justified. What that man did to those little girls is horrible. But those women let their emotions get the best of them and stooped down to his level. It's a hard thing to say however...it wasn't our little girls that were put through something like that. I'm sure I would feel different if it was my child.

Answer 3

The end justifies the means.

I remember in Africa not too long ago the victim had the option to give the punishment to the men who raped her due to the justice system being lax and corrupt. So the whole village captured them and they were whipped in public.

The justice system i find is becoming too lenient and it seems most times they get off on mental instability and released on parole etc after 3-5 yrs. Which I think is not fair to the victim but also to the community.

They should have the death penalty back for cases of murder like Martin Bryant rather than using our taxes to pay for their living expenses. Plus this will solve a lot of overpopulation problems. How many people have criminal records? I would rather have the innocent living happily rather than the criminals living freely and influencing others. Treason should be a more serious crime and I'm sure it was death penalty then too.

Rape should be chemical castration or death penalty why give them the option to do it again?

They should lose human rights since they don't treat their victims as humans in the first place.

Answer 4

i think your imagination is kinda creepy, but whatever

no, not justified

Answer 5

I definitely believe it was justified. I would probably do the same!

The man did not care about the feeling of the children, so why should anyone care about his? or his private part?

I think he should have been put on death row.

These children will be scarred for life now.

Answer 6

I can understand why the women did what they did. I'm not sure I condone what they did but then I've never been in the situation they were in. I don't think any of us can truley judge how these women reacted unless we have been in the same or similar situation. If someone hurt my little girl, I think I would be capable of anything. It doesn't make it right, but protecting your child comes before right or wrong.  

Answer 7

How many times are you going to ask this ridiculous question it's morbid, disgusting and not lickly to be true anyways.

The man was very sick and shouldn't have done those acts on innocent girls but, he was more than likely just a victim himself. The cycle of abuse once started can be difficult to stop, No one has any reason to hurt another person unless being hurt first by someone else.

Also I would like to point out that despite popular belief rats/mice definitely do not eat cheese. I haven't tested it but I don't recall ever hearing that they would consume honey.

I doubt that this story actually happened, nor do I feel that tourture in any form is acceptable. If we live in a society that practices barbaric acts such as torture we will be truely ignorant and sad.

Does anyone really feel that we should promote tourture as a reasonable means of justice? Two wrongs don't make a right stop hurting each other and these type of behaviors wont happen to more innocent people

Answer 8

I agree with Bev M (above).  I think he deserved much more than what he got.

He still would not have experienced the type of fear and pain (physical and psychological) as each one of his victims would have.

Also the consequences he had to suffer alone don't even compare to how much the victims and their families have had to suffer for the rest of their lives. His actions didn't just affect his life, they affected many many people.

This coward's physical scars would have healed, probably as would the girls' but, those who have fallen victim to his merciless crimes have had to try to continue to live as well as deal with their anguish and the sorrow of their loved ones for the rest of their lives.

I believe in reincarnation and also that what goes around comes around. I hope that savage suffers greatly for many of his lives to come.

Answer 9

I think it's understandable. I would probably want to do the same in their situation. However, I don't think it was justice. Justice should never involve physical torture or pain or violence, not in a civilised society.

The crimes he did were terrible, but I think this was retaliation, not justice, and I think there's a difference. Justice shouldn't be changed by emotions, or venegence, it should be objective. And the punishment for this crime should have been life imprisonment, not mutilation.