Would Shane worne have been a greater captain than Ricky ponting?

Question

Would Shane worne have been a greater captain than Ricky ponting?

Answer 1

Shane Warne is greatest australian captain.

Answer 2

If not for the unwanted attention he got in the media for wrong

reasons, he would definitely be the captain. I think he would

have enjoyed it and also deserved being one of the senior

players. It would be hard to tell if he would have been more

successful than Ponting. But I think he would have been given

that he had great players around him.

Answer 3

Warnie would never be made a captain, there are some internal reasons.

Answer 4

Yes.he coud have been

He did a great job as a skipper for his team & that proved what he can do whenever he is wanted.Even look at the victory achieved by them against deccan chargers.He is a great skipper & a great cricketer for australians for a greater australia.He still has lot to do.Ricky brought them 2 world cups & so he as also done a great job.But the team warne had was completely under-rated team & he won the cup with that team itself.

Answer 5

Yes Shane worne have been a greater captain than Ricky ponting.  Ponting is a liar and cheapskate !

Answer 6

As for indiscretions, you might remember that Ponting was decked cold outside a Sydney pub by a polynesian bouncer.  He had his wild days too.

Now whatever your feelings and opinions about IPL, do not underestimate its competitiveness.

Consider this; Warne led a rag tag team that had little bonding and unknown potential  to victory.  Ponting leads a  team that is ambitious, talented, disciplined and focused.

What might have been, nobody knows but it would be hard to deny that Warne has one of the most cunning  brains in cricketing history

Answer 7

May be but I cant see anything wrong with Ponting 16 consecutive victories and much more what else could Warney have done

Ponting Got the best of his team out .I don't think there was anything left that Warney could have Doe But yeah Warne is the best

Answer 8

yes

Answer 9

As a completely unbiased onlooker, I don't think he could have equalled Ponting's record.

Answer 10

I do not think so.  He would not have been able to command the same respect from the players which Ponting has been able to do.

Answer 11

No, he wouldn't have come anywhere near it. He doesn't have the self control & concentration of Ponting & I don't think he would get the same respect from his team either. Like his predecessors, Ponting was a captain who put up with no c**p & commanded respect just by his own actions.He led by example in other words.

Answer 12

No..To be a good captain it takes discipline,and i think we all know that is something Shane Warne deeply lacked whilst he was Vice Captain of Australia...

And i seriously doubt Warnie could have gotten Australia to a record 16-0 wins in Test matches...

He might have made a good IPL captain but that is only over a what 2 month period...

Answer 13

YES!!!... Ricky cheats!!!!!!