Would You Trade Carlos Beltran and Tejada for Jimmy Rollins and Nate McClouth?

Question

A manager in my league has just offered me this deal. Here is my current outfield:

Bobby Abreu

Carlos Beltran

Shane Victorino

Carl Crawford

Any thoughts?

Answer 1

Homie......BELTRAN  and the METS are a Hitting team that hasnt caught their stride yet. They usually play better in the second half and BELTRAN is known for his second half totals.....U have a very talented outfield and dont believe that u will need the advantage that ROLLINS gives u in 1 position. I say stick it out with TEJADA and youll be sitting on top lookin down on the rest....

Answer 2

Yes, Jimmy Rollins and McClouth is a nice little upgrade check the projected stats and current rankings for yourself.

Answer 3

No.

Answer 4

bro rollins is a top 10 player when hes at his best, and hes been stealin bases like crazy.  mclouth is the best player on the pirates, and has only upside whereas beltran is on the decline clearly over these past few seasons.  I look for tejada to cool off as he already has, the astros offense has other strengths and he is also on the decline.  you will be highly increasing at the shortstop position, and from the looks of your outfield mclouth fits right in with the fast run scorers victorino and crawford.  i'd go for it man all the way