Would it really matter if I traded Andre Johnson for Chad Johnson? I know both of them are injured.....?

Question

but I like Chad more. I think, if he's healthy, has the potential to have a better season than Andre because he has the better QB and is in a better offense. Should I make the trade?

My Team (12 Team H2H League)

QB - Carson Palmer

RB - Joseph Addai

RB - Darren McFadden

WR - Laveranues Coles

WR - Andre Johnson

RB/WR - Santana Moss

TE - Kellen Winslow

K - Shane Graham

DST - Giants

Bench

Jason Campbell

Ahman Green

Leon Washington

D.J. Hackett

DST - Ravens

Answer 1

Keep Andre for sure. He will put up more numbers this season and I'm pretty sure that they will both be ready to play. I like your team by the way, solid.

Answer 2

I think you should keep Andre Johnson but i think Chad should be ready for the start of the season but I dont know about it because they just resigned Chris Henry  

Answer 3

chad johnson has had a consistent career. when andre played last season, he was great, but he didn't last a full season. although chad johnson is a great receiver, i still think you should keep andre because he's the true #1 in houston. chad has houshmandzadeh and the new chris henry to take away his receptions.

Answer 4

Keep Andre Johnson. I think Chad Johnson and Carson Palmer are going to have lower than predicted numbers.

Answer 5

i think andre johnson will put up better numbers than chad johnson. we don't know how serious his injury is and they're going to go back to run first pass 2nd ordeal if im not mistaken (cincinati).