Would this trade work out in the MLB?

Question

Phillies get:

Magglio Ordonez (Tigers) OF

Bobby Seay (Tigers) P

James Skelton (AA Sea Wolves) C

Tigers get:

Pedro Feliz (Phillies) 3B

Carlos Carrasco (AA Phillies) SP

Geoff Jenkins (Phillies) OF

Answer 1

In terms of players received by the Tigers they absolutely get ripped off but if they should need to trim their payroll a bit they just might consider it (and people still ask me why the Red Sox traded Manny...)

Answer 2

Tigers would get nobody. They trade one of the best players for what Feliz? Tigers would never make this trade.

Answer 3

Tigers would get Ripped off

Answer 4

It would be a horrible trade for the Tigers.

Answer 5

it wouldnt work the tigers wouldnt give up magglio for some medioker players

Answer 6

unfair for tigers

Answer 7

No.  Good for the Phillies.  BAD BAD BAD for the Tigers.

Answer 8

You must be a Philly fan, why don't you throw in Cabrera and Guillen too!!!

Answer 9

i do not think this would happen. The Tigers would demand more power for Magglio, who is a big part of the offense, than Feliz (who doesnt hit for average, or much power) or Geoff Jenkins (who isnt getting any younger)...Although, i dont know the minor league players, DET may want a prospect pitcher, but one that is closer to getting into the bigs than a AA player.  

Answer 10

um no. Wayyy to lopsided.

Answer 11

What value would the Tigers get out of this trade? Why would they want two 34 year old borderline decent career players? Detroit would be out of their minds if they did this.