Would you accept this fantasy baseball trade?

Question

I'm in an 8 team league, homeruns, rbis and strikeouts bring in the most points. I'm in 4th place right now and my teams raking at ever position except catcher.

I get

Russell Martin

BJ Upton

Dan Haren

Roy Oswalt

I give up

Ian Kinsler

Ryan Doumit

Nate Mclouth

Jake Peavy

Dice K

Trade seems fair, but should I be asking for more?

Answer 1

Don't take it.  I think you'd just be giving up a little too much.

Answer 2

Bad Trade. Kinsler and Doumit are doing better than Russell Martin and BJ Upton. Peavy and Dice K are better than Haren and Oswalt. Mclouth is doing good. This is a horrible trade for you.

Answer 3

I wouldnt do it. Doumit is solid. Try it without mclouth. If he takes it then ya.

Answer 4

noooooo

Answer 5

would you give up Kinsler for Martin? Peavy for Haren? Daisuke for Oswalt? Even Upton for Mclouth and Doumit is questionable. No chance in ******* h**l.

Answer 6

giving up just a little to much with Jake and Dice they are strike out monsters. And Ian kinsler is just having to good of a season.

Answer 7

Do not do this trade. Oswalt is hurt, Arizona is under  .500 now, Peavy is a strikeout king.

Answer 8

No, Don't do it... just do Mclouth for Martin if you are just looking for a catcher... Oswalt just got injured too... the guy who offered you that trade is a sleeze.

Answer 9

If all you're trying to do is upgrade your catcher, Doumit really isn't that much worse than Martin, at least at this point in the season....so giving up Kinsler and those two good pitchers seems like a bad deal for you.