Would you accept this fantasy football trade?

Question

Jason Witten (Dal. TE)

Edgerrin James (Ari. RB)

Derek Anderson (Cle. QB)

for

Carson Palmer (Cin. QB)

Kellen Winslow (Cle. TE)

Ronnie Brown (Mia. RB)

Answer 1

Hmm - it's a fairly even trade - I would say the side that gets Winslow, Brown, and Palmer will get players who I think will put up more combined points - but this one really could go either way.  If you're on either side, and you like the players that are coming to you, I'd say go for it.  You're not really going to lose or win in this one.

Answer 2

No. You have the better 3 players.

Answer 3

Palmer is better than Anderson

WInslow is better than Witten

James is better than Brown

I would say thats a very even trade, the 2nd team is losing alittle but of run game by losing James but in the long run Iwould say team two wins by alittle but. So As long as Im team 1 I would accept that deal.

Answer 4

I'm guessing you're getting Witten, James, and Anderson? If I were you (and those would be the players you're getting), yes, I'd accept it. You'd be getting three dependable players who are destined for breakout years.

Answer 5

if you are the one getting palmer and the crew. otherwise it is a horrible trade. palmer and anderson should be a wash as well as witten and winslow. brown will be a stud if he stays healthy while james will struggle to a mediocre year in az.

Answer 6

Yes if you're the one giving up Winslow

Answer 7

I would give up James, Anderson and Witten for Palmer, Winslow and Brown without much of a second thought.

Answer 8

I think whoever gets Palmer, Winslow, and Brown wins the trade.

Edge and Brown are pretty even, brown is usually better but has injury issues.

Witten is better than Winslow, but not by much.

Carson should be alot better than Anderson.

Answer 9

Depends. Do I get Palmer/Winslow/Brown? If so, then I'd take that trade. If not, then I wouldn't. I'm not sold on Anderson having a repeat performance from last year, and James is old AND on a sucky team. Witten's great, but Winslow's getting to be right up there with him. Brown is injury prone, but has MUCH higher upside than James. And I like Palmer to rebound from last year. He was nearly as good as Manning the two years before.

Answer 10

no

Answer 11

no way, palmer is an upgrade from anderson, but winslow is a downgrade from witten.  so it kinda comes down to brown vs. james.  not excited about either, but i just don't trust ronnie brown.  I say no deal