Would you do these trades?

Question

Send Roethlisberger away for Jon Kitna and Vernon Davis(I have two other good QB's on roster)

Send Steve Slaton away for Rudi Johnson

Send Jason Campbell away for Matt Ryan

Answer 1

i like the roethisberger trade...depending on who your other QB is though...

Keep Steve Slaton.....

Trade Jason Campbell for Matt Ryan...

Answer 2

Kitna is the most underrated QB in the league.  Every year he finishes in the top 7 or so in points.  He is the only QB who has 4 good WR's.  If you need a TE, I would do it.  If you don't, keep Roethlisberger. Johnson could be good if traded like the Bengals are trying to do or if he ends up being the starter in Cinci.  Slaton has upside but there are 4 RB's trying for the 1 spot. AT best he is probably splitting carries.  I'd take the chance on Rudi.  Campbell and Ryan are pretty much useless right now.  Neither is even on a team in my league.  Campbell has a better chance this year.

Answer 3

NO to all...Slaton has a better chance of starting than Rudi

Answer 4

VDavis hasnt done anything yet and Roth is a top5 QB u gotta get at least 3-4 round value for him in return(Chad Johnson, Santoniio Holmes, Fred Taylor). I wouldnt mess with Houston or Denver RBs, plus Rudi getting traded means he will get carries somewhere. Jason Campbell is way better than Matt Ryan.

Answer 5

No, Roethlisberger put up huge numbers last year (he's first year in the system so you know this year will be equal to if not better), Kitna lost his Offensive Coordinator and with Vernon Davis well the tight end doesn't get a lot of looks in the Martz systerm.

Yes, Johnson will probably be traded to another team soon and I'm sure it's going to be a team who needs a running back.

No, while Ryan may look good in the offseason no rookie has ever had a good year when he started his first year.