Would you draft McFadden or Grant in a keeper league?

Question

Standard yahoo format

other backs:Alexander,Cadillac,Green,L. Jordan

Answer 1

Grant because it is unknown how McFadden'll fair out and everyone knows that grant absolutely rocks!

Answer 2

in a keeper league, mcfadden could pay big dividends..i dont see grant having the same success this year unless favre is still in the lineup.  Defenses wont be nearly as keyed in on stopping the pass, and will be able to focus on the run.  Grant will struggle.  Mcfadden will be money, maybe not this year with fargas taking carries and a weak O-line, but mcfadden will be the man in years to come.

Answer 3

As long as McFadden is in Oakland, he will never be amazing.  Stick with Grant.

Answer 4

Pick Grant, but moniter his statis

Answer 5

I would do Grant b/c you might be able to redraft Mccfaden. Mccfaden wont being doing as much as people think this year and Grant is going to have a solid year as the number 1 back where Fargas is the number 1 back in Oakland

Answer 6

I love the Raiders and McFadden but id have to take Grant just because we dont know how McFadden will do..

Answer 7

Trade up and get them both

Answer 8

Ryan Grant for sure. After his 950 yard in only half of a seasons effort, he will have a great season this year. A new QB at the helm in green bay and you can expect to see them using the run a little more.

Answer 9

I would take Grant, he played well last year.

Answer 10

Grant could be a one hit wonder, plus he's holding out.  With Grant projected at 13 and McFadden at 33 see how it plays out.  I wouldn't reach for either...

Gore should a consideration as well, this year in a Martz offense.