Would you have done this trade, Carlos Quentin for M. Bradley and....?

Question

...pretty much a throw away player?

I got this trade:

I give Quentin

I get Bradley and Jason Michaels (Pit)

Would you have done this? Basically...who would you think will be better for the season, Quentin or Bradley? I rejected this trade and I dunno if it was the right move.

Help please.

Answer 1

I'd say it's pretty even. The only down side the Bradley has over Quentin is that Bradley is always hurt and probably will spend time on the DL before the seasons over. Hold on to Quentin.

Answer 2

would definitely take bradley. He is having a career year on a good hitting texas team

Answer 3

Jason Michaels is basically a waiver wire player and you would have to drop him or someone else.

Here is your dilemma.

Quentin is hitting  R49 HR17 RBI 56 SB4 .ave281

Bradley is hitting  R47 HR15 RBI 48 SB4 .ave332

Bradley has done that with 30 less at bats.

I would personally keep Quentin. There is little chance that he would be suspended. Bradley is having a great year, but has already had a few "situations" which indicates he might be out of control AGAIN.

Answer 4

quientin is better at this point hold on to him