Would you make this fantasy baseball trade?

Question

Someone wants my player who is Ryan Braun of Mil.- (3B and OF) for Adam Dunn of cin. (OF) for friday the 13th. Would you trade?

Answer 1

No.  The only stat you will be helping yourself in is K's!  Brauns a stud.

Answer 2

Just to add to what the others are saying, Braun is late 1st to 2nd round material. Dunn is taken no where near that.

Braun will give you 30+ HR's with a much better average, RBIs, and SB's.

Decline the offer and stick with Braun.

Answer 3

No way, that is the worst trade ever for you, decline in a heartbeat. Good Luck.

Answer 4

Without a doubt - Decline the offer

First - Braun is eligible to play both 3B and OF which instantly makes him more valuable than Dunn.  In general, 3B is a much more difficult position to fill than OF.

Second - Braun & Dunn's power numbers (HR, RBI, Runs) are relatively equal, however, Braun's batting average is significantly higher than Dunn's.  Neither of them steal too often, but Braun has a few more steals than Dunn.  Braun is also ranked higher according to Yahoo than Dunn is.

Hope this helps!  Good luck!

Answer 5

decline! decline! decline!