Would you make this trade??

Question

I have Kurt Warner and Frank Gore. Someone is offering me Steven Jackson and Laveranues Coles in exchange for those two guys. Should I make this trade?

My roster is as follows:

Randy Moss

Terrell Owens

Brandon Marshall

Javon Walker

Frank Gore

Ryan Grant

Willie Parker

Michael Turner

Chester Taylor

Dallas Clark

Brett Favre

Kurt Warner

Marc Bulger

Rob Bironas

Geen Bay DEF.

Philly DEF.

Answer 1

Yes yes yes without a second thought. Jackson is a 1400yd 15 TD guy. He is a top 3 pick. this guy is a complete moron. Make this trade ASAP!!!

EDIT : Mono is a complete and total moron. Unless your league rewards QBs ten-fold over RBs (which virtually NO league does) make this trade. Warner may be the teachers pet, but you have Favre and Bulger. Why on earth would you need a 50 year old injury prone QB on your team when you have an option to get possibly THE MOST PRODUCTIVE back in the NFL this year. Mono, your a r****d. The difference between Frank Gore and Jackson is LIGHT YEARS. There is no comparison. Gore = 1100 6tds. Jackson = 1400 15 tds. No comparison. Period.

Answer 2

I probably would make that trade.  Steven Jackson is a better back than Frank Gore.  The other two guys in the trade don't really matter since they will both be backups.

Answer 3

I would not make the trade. In Arizona there is no rushing attack as Edgerrin James is really starting to get older, Leinart clearly isn't the starter while Warner is a coach favorite and won't lose his starting role, and Warner will be throwing all day to the Cardinals two elite receivers Boldin and Fitzgerald. You also have three QBs, all who have great upsides, but two who might succumb to injury (Bulger because his O-line has crumbled in the past, Warner because he can't evade hits), and it would be smart to have both in your pocket just in case one goes down, then you have the other, and both should put up great stats. this year. Lav Coles is going to have a good year, and I do like Jackson over Gore, but your receivers are excellent, and your running backs are already great.

If you do want to make the deal, shift gears and offer a wideout, I would capitalize on Javon Walker's big name and trade him because the Raiders had to beg him not to retire this year (after signing him), and trade him either straight up for Lav Coles, or package him with one of your running backs other than Gore for S-Jax and Lav Coles. But what small margin you gain from having S-Jax over Gore, and Lav Coles rather than one of your star receivers, is negligible compared to having a QB who runs a pass-heavy offense with two of the NFL's best wideouts to use, in a worst case scenario, if Bulger goes down, in a best case scenario, as someone you can match up against poor pass defenses week-by-week and get huge production from the QB spot with. Acquiring S-Jax & Lav Coles is nice, but you have the parts to make a better deal where you gain more and give less, I would not make that trade, your team is -excellent-.

Answer 4

Yes  

Answer 5

YEA!!!!!

Answer 6

Yes, I would for sure do that trade. Kurt Warner shouldn't even be owned in most leagues in my opinion. Gore is very good, but Steven Jackson is just as good if not better. Coles is a decent fantasy wide receiver that will add depth to your team.  

Answer 7

heck yes steven jackson is a beast and laveranues coles has brett farve and will have a huge year