Would you put Roy Keane in the same group as Joey Barton?

Question

On the football pitch of course. Disregarding their off-field problems, do you think their attitude was similar on the field?

Answer 1

No. Roy Keane is a talented yet violent man. Joey Barton is a thug who can kick a ball.

Answer 2

No Keane is a legend and is coming along very nicely as a manager.....Barton is a  waste of space.

Answer 3

Roy Keane's bollox are in the correct place,Barton's are hanging off his forehead!.

Answer 4

The question is a huge insult to Roy Keane

Answer 5

YES,,,,,,BOTH NUTTERS

Answer 6

no. simply the fact is joey barton will never be the great captain Keano was for the United faithful !!!

Answer 7

No , Barton isnt fit to tie Roy Keanes boot laces

Answer 8

No, Keane is a much better player!

Answer 9

I don't think you can. Keane was  10 times the player Barton is. Attitude wise, they both have it but release it in different ways. At one point Keane would have been in my all time greatest players list.....then he made that tackle on AIHaaland and I thought what a tw@t. Still no comparison though.

Answer 10

whats wrong with you supporting an Irish team then, i have been to see Glentoran and they have true fans.

Getting back to the question i think they are alike.

okay, thanks for the reply

Answer 11

No cos Keane was a good player

Answer 12

roy keane legend joey barton not so

Answer 13

Pusssys the pair of them

Answer 14

No not at all, keane was a good player and leader. Barton in the other hand is a good football player but an utter disgrace to the game on and off pitch.

Answer 15

Keane was world class.  Barton is Vinnie Jones with even less talent.  Just an idiotic chav who made it into football through the back door!!  Or pleasing someone with hot oil rubs ......

Answer 16

Keane was a great player Barton isn't fit to clean his boots NO comparison.....

Answer 17

Maybe for passion on the field but that's about as far as the similarities go.