Would you rather have Buddy or Fev in your team?

Question

Both these guys cop a bit of flack, so who would you want on your team.

Answer 1

Definitely Buddy , he is a superstar , have never seen such a big fella run like him . He's such an athlete and so big and strong and talented. His kicking for goal will only get better with time. If I was a Richmond supporter I'd be crying every time I saw him play, I mean how could they pick Tambling ahead of Buddy. I don't understand why Buddy wasn't a number 1 pick.  Fev is a great player too but his best is behind him and he is always going to have attitude problems. Buddy's only attitude problem is that sometimes he looks like he loves himself , well he should love himself because he is just a champion at such a young age and I think he'II go down in history as one of the all time greats of the game.  

Answer 2

I would take Buddy any time! Fev is only good when he feels like it!

Haha, Sodz, you made me laugh so much! I agree!

Answer 3

Buddy is younger and can get better accuracy wise, I'd take Buddy

Answer 4

BUDYY : )

four words -

legend infront of goal.

Answer 5

FEV

he is GOD

Answer 6

buddy of course beacuse im a hawk supporter and i wouldnt want him anywhere else  

Answer 7

i  wouldn't want either player. i'd rather our team SHARING the ball around and kicking goals, instead of relying on one of these guys

Answer 8

Fevola is more reliable (on Field) so I would have him right now,both are brilliant footy players though.

Answer 9

Lance Franklin is a lot more consitant than Fevola and probly not as much of an idoit to, but Fevola kicking a goal can lift a team a whole stack, if Fev doesnt kick goals Carlton doesnt know who to turn to for goals, but if franklin doesnt, roughead can easly kick 5. Fevola is more of a Legend and will have more goals that Franklin at the end of their playing lifes. it will be more like dunstall and ablett competing for the collman medal  

Answer 10

buddy!!! collingwood will die without buddy! pack your bags and move from hawthorn to collingwood mate!

Answer 11

buddy.

Answer 12

Buddy, he is such an exciting young player!  

Answer 13

definitely Buddy. I can't stand Fev with his arrogance and his bimbo wife.

Answer 14

Buddy champion

Answer 15

I would pick Fevola now as he is at the peak of his career and will in the next 1-2 years kick 100+ goals, but in 3 years time I would chose Buddy as he is only 21(?), but the only concern would be he would get injured at a young age and not be back where he is now.

Answer 16

buddy

he is more diciplined than fev i think.

and he is younger so he has more years left in him

Answer 17

I hate Buddy and i hate Fev. you never no which buddy and fev will turn up coz they are both unpredictable. hate fev coz he plays for carlton and hate buddy coz everyone loves him when hes not all that good. and yea i agree with sodz- he prob would p**s all over my players and collingwood has enough to deal with than p**s.

Answer 18

Fev.

Buddy loves himself too much. I'm waiting to see how he goes in finals pressure games. He's failed, when the crunch has been on, before.

Answer 19

Buddy by a mile, come home to the west mate, we will welcome you with open arms!

Answer 20

Buddy any day.  Fev's an idiot.

Answer 21

Definitely Buddy - He is a better player and less of a moron, plus fev will only be around for a few more years.

How on earth would anyone seriously choose fev over buddy?

Answer 22

If I had to choose, it would be Buddy, but I am very happy with the boys at Bomberland, and if it meant that having Buddy, somebody would miss out, I would rather not have him.   Hawthorn deserves some good players and a Premiership, specially for Crawfs

Answer 23

Buddy for sure, Fev is just too unpredictable, you never know when he will stuff up!

Answer 24

Neither,as they are both to big for their boots. happy with what we have in Geelong.

Answer 25

buddy :)

Answer 26

Good question. They both have their pros and cons. Buddys a brilliant forward who'd be one of the best ever if only he could kick straight while Fev's a strong marking forward with an long accurate kick but he acts like a girl sometimes. So if you taught one to stop sooking and the other one to kick accurately, they would both get 100 goals a season easily.

Mind you, a lot of what they do also depends on how good the midfield is at delivering the ball to them as well.

But at the moment I'd choose Buddy purely on age.

Answer 27

Buddy (:

Answer 28

Budev or Feddy for me - both unpredictable geniuses

Answer 29

Buddy - Fev is a w**ker. I really hate the way he gives out cheap shots when the backs are clearing the ball. I couldn't believe he wasn't reported in the Sydney game a few weeks ago.

Answer 30

Buddy he is a West Australian boy and I can't stand Fev so he would be the last player I would want in my team.

Answer 31

Fev - at the moment

Buddy - in the future.

Carn the blues.