Would you rather have Lance Berkman or Ryan Braun?

Question

A few weeks ago I traded Lance Berkman and Ken Griffey Jr. for Ryan Braun! I looked at this trade as more of a 1 for 1 deal because Griffey is injury-prone and besides, I have too many outfielders (Pence, Young, Hunter, Cabrera) . Was this a good trade for me?

Answer 1

Very good trade as Berkman begins to falter.

Braun is a stud. I love Berkboy, but not as much as Braun.

Yes, good trade for the season.

Good luck. Have fun.

Answer 2

Yeah, braun will own berkman in the long run. Good Luck.

Answer 3

I'd rather have Berkman's better avg, steals, walks...

he's number one in the yahoo game!  

Not a good trade.

Answer 4

well if this is a keepers league than i would say good trade

actually it was a good trade either way

Answer 5

Ryan Bruan.  No question.  What a good trade for whoever gets Bruan.  Maybe ask for someone besides Jr. that you need.

Answer 6

Berkman is a notorious streaky hitter...good and bad. I don't expect him to continue this pace. Braun on the other hand is a little bit more consistent. It's pretty close at this point since Braun is heating up. It's a trade I wouldn't have made a few weeks ago because why trade the best offensive player of the season. But now the tables have turned offensively so I guess it's turning out to be a good trade.

Answer 7

No dude. Berkman will outproduce braun i think.it would help to see ur roster and know what kind of league it is but overall i don't like it.

fantasybaseballcafe.com

^^^^best site ever, pos ur questions get tons of answers ;) for free and easy

Answer 8

As of right now that trade does not look all that great, even though Braun is a beast Berkman has put up better numbers.  Berkman has put up a nice little hitting streak lately.  They are both very streaky and when you have them on their good week, they are two of the most dominant players in baseball.

Answer 9

sry dude, these other guys r suckin up. it was a bad trade.

Answer 10

Good trade.  Braun is better then Berkman, has more upside, and is on a better team.  Griffey means nothing if you have many OF's.  Braun and Youkilus= THE JEWS ARE TAKING OVER MLB!! JEW POWER!!!!!