Would you rather read Cosmogirl or Seventeen?

Question

I've heard some good and bad things about each magazine. I heard that Seventeen promotes promiscuity and that Cosmogirl! has some shallow articles. Although, every magazine has its flaws.

Answer 1

seventeen- just a little bit of promiscuity, but mostly it just helps you be comfortable with who you are

i hate cosmogirl though

Answer 2

i loved seventeen, but i remember getting the first cosmogirl in like oct 2001, it had melissa joan heart on it but i didnt fancy the mag that much!

Answer 3

I read both magazines and they both just totally and completely rock. They are similar and yet VERY different from one another. Both magazines have good articles, great advice, and are very useful to teenage girls like myself.

Answer 4

Seventeen is way better...

But I prefer some Cosmopolitan myself =] the good stuff!

Answer 5

i prefer 17 better fashion :)

Answer 6

Seventeen.

All the way.

I think theres more to read in Seventeen...

Answer 7

I prefer Seventeen, but thats my opinion :)

Answer 8

id read cosmogirl

Answer 9

cosmo girl has nothing to read but thats my opinion i have read both i deffinitly perfer seventeen magizine i love it i read it every month i ever ordered it to be sent to my house!

hope this helps sweetie!

Answer 10

I like Cosmo girl Think its better !

Answer 11

17

Answer 12

I like Seventeen. Who cares if it "promotes promiscuity"? I think it's entertaining to read.

Answer 13

I would rather read Foam.... Maybe Cosmopolitan if i feel like reading something dirty

Answer 14

Seventeen is the best.

Answer 15

Cosmogirl by far!!! Seventeen has too many adverts......

Best

Blue

Answer 16

why not read something that will actually expand your mind? a book about history, politics, economics, philosophy, science, religion....

not some magazine about "100 ways to get him into bed" or some stupid thing about what celebs have the best bodies. Makes me want to puke.

Answer 17

i get both, but i look forward to reading seventeen more.

but..my fav magazine is teenvogue :D

Answer 18

I don't think Seventeen pomotes promiscuity at all. They just say that if you ARE, then be careful. But no I've read so many Seventeen articles telling you to wait until you're ready and not to do it for the wrong reasons. But yes I like Seventeen more than Cosmogirl. I have a subscription :)

And ignore those guys who say the magazines are shallow, because they haven't even read them.

Answer 19

seventeen, it has more of the things I like in it.

Answer 20

Seventeen

Answer 21

I love both!

Seventeen has really good beauty tips

Cosmo Girl is all about fashion and has good ideas in it.

I get both of them and couldn't choose only one.

But if I HAD to, i would choose CosmoGirl

They have more info and cool stuff in it.

Answer 22

I like Seventeen better...they do not promote promiscuity!!  They teach about safe s*x and how to be more responsible sexually (because teen pregnancy and STDs are on the rise in America, and Seventeen teaches you how to prevent that or treat it).  They have real life stories, health topics, how to be more confident and responsible, etc. and they've been around since the 1940s...it's the classic teenage girl magazine...

Although I do like Cosmogirl! as well!  It's Cosmopolitan that's the uber-shallow one.