Would you tell a friend another friend's personal secret?

Question

because my friend got mad at me because good friends tell everyone everything and i wouldn't tell him the secret. he also called me a bad friend for not telling him. doesn't that make a good friend for keeping a secret? i mean, i can't break my promise. and if i did that would make me a bad friend, right?

Answer 1

you shouldnt tell your friend the secret unless its ok with your other friend. your friend should respect you because you are being loyal to your other friend and they would probably want you to do the same for them.  if your friend got mad at you because you wouldnt tell a secret then their not a good friend.  talk to the other friend with the secret and ask them if its ok to tell the other friend and if its not then your friend has to respect you.  i have had problems with this kind of thing also.

Answer 2

i have a best friend that i tell him everything and anything b/c he doesnt tell anyone anything that i say b/c we have such a good friendship. if u feel that u should keep the secret then dont tell him if he is truly ur friend he will understand

Answer 3

Makes you a good friend for not telling and makes him a bad one for trying to force it out of you.