Would you trade JRoll, BJ Ryan and MCabrerra for Hamilton BJUpton and Lincecum?

Question

This is in a 10 team H2H league in which we name 4 keepers every year (3 pos and 1 P)

I am getting killed offensively nearly every week.

Answer 1

I hope U didn't do that trade..I just caught this question,and realized what a terrible trade it is for you!

Jroll+Miggy are young 1st round keepers on explosive teams.

Hamilton is having a career year,and Upton is improving,but

I think you are getting the shaft in this deal.

~Good Luck!~

Answer 2

yes!! the guy who is getting your three is losing out, BJ ryan is losing it this year, miguel cabrera is going down hill, jimmy rollins is ok but bj uptons speed will replace that... getting tim lincecum and hamitlon are the best parts of this trade