Would you trade Lance Berkman and Rickie Weeks for Ian Kinsler and Matt Holliday?

Question

This is not a 5x5 league. It is a hitters only league with H2H matchups. 1pt for single, 2 for a double....5 for a HR......1.5 for a RBI, etc. Berkman is best player in the league and Weeks is a decent throw in. Kinsler is studly and Holliday was a first rounder in every draft. What would you guys do?

Answer 1

idk

Answer 2

no that is stupid

Answer 3

Yes. Sell high on Berkman. Kinsler is a power hitter and has speed and gets a good average unlike Weeks. Holliday will do go once returning from the DL.

Answer 4

No way would I trade Berkman unless I got Utley or Pujols back in a 1 for 1 deal.

Answer 5

lance berkman has been so great this year. i would not trade him. rickie weeks has a bad average, but he's not that bad overall. holliday is weeks from coming back. kinsler has been a great hitter, but berkman is just too good.