Would you trade Pujols, kelly Johnson, and Joba for Prince, Brian Roberts, and Zambrano?

Question

Would you trade Pujols, kelly Johnson, and Joba for Prince, Brian Roberts, and Zambrano?

Answer 1

yea, that would be good, but one more player for pujols since he in my opinion is worth 2 players.

Answer 2

Yes I would. Pujols is injured right now, and has another potential injury to worry about with his elbow. Prince Fielder, while not doing as well at this point as expected, can still catch fire and reach 40 HRs...maybe more. Kelly Johnson is alright, but Brian Roberts is better. Plus there is a chance Roberts can be traded to a contender before the deadline. For a while I've heard that there's a good chance he could be traded to the Cubs. He'd score even more runs in that lineup. And there isn't much of a contest between Joba and Zambrano. Joba is very talented and pitches for the Yankees, which always counts for something. But he's only made two starts in his career. It will be a while before he comes into his own as an elite pitcher. Zambrano has already proven to be an ace and pitches for the best team in baseball right now. Enough said.

Answer 3

It would be very hard to not to make that trade.  It guess it kind of depends on whether you trust Pujols health or not.  You will be losing a lot of RBI's and power getting rid of Pujols and Johnson but would gain a good deal from picking up Zambrano.  Do what you feel in your gut but personally I would hang on to Pujols, Johnson and Joba especially if I had another option at first.  Possible Free Agents like Mike Jacobs would make it easier to hold on to Pujols.

Answer 4

DECLINE. GOOD LUCK.

Answer 5

I'd do it straight up.  Pujols ain't worth two with an ailing calf.

this fantasy baseball is getting a little old, football anyone?

Answer 6

Yes.  I would rather have Prince, Roberts, and Big Z

Answer 7

I would do it in a second. Pujols will be out for a while and Prince has just awakened from his deep slumber. Brian Roberts is much better then Kelly Johnson, and Zambrano is better then Joba. Joba can't even get through enough innings to give you a quality start. Zambrano is a top fantasy pitcher. Make the trade.

Answer 8

Yep. It would be hard to say no to that.