Would you trade Ryan Ludwick for Jason Bay?

Question

They're pretty similar..

Ludwick has slightly more HR and RBI, and a higher avg.. but Bay has more AB's, more BB's, and he's on a much more favorable lineup now..

Answer 1

It seems like you answered your own question.

Bay has a track record of productivity(minus last season), and he is also in that potent Boston lineup.

I'd fully recommend taking Bay for Ludwick, just because of the potential for better stats in these last few months from a Boston player.

While STL has a good lineup, it's not as good as Boston's