Would you trade mcgahee and crayton for julius jones and holt?

Question

Would you trade mcgahee and crayton for julius jones and holt?

Answer 1

McGahee is coming off knee surgery, and last year he hardly ever saw the end zone.  He isn't helping your team much.  That being said, Jones is the same type of back that will be pulled in goal line situations.  I would say that this part of the trade is about even.

I would bet crayton has a better season than Holt.  Holt is getting too old to be consistently good, and Crayton is penciled in as the number two receiver in one of the best offenses in football right now.  

So, don't take this trade, you could get something better for those two players.

Answer 2

No. Jones might lose his job to Morris and Crayton should have a solid year.

Answer 3

NO!