Y wont west coast deal with carlton anymore was it becasue of judd

Question

just wanna noe

Answer 1

They wont deal with Carlton? really? how do you know?

Must be coz of Judd!!

Answer 2

Because Carlton were dishonourable in the trade for Judd and they, and everyone else, knows it.  They might think that they got a bargain, but it would probably have been a better deal in the long run if they'd kept on-side with a club as big as West Coast.  Carlton might think that they are a bigger club, but in the modern business world, they are nowhere close.

Answer 3

Thanks for all of the best answers! =)

Yes, West Coast won't deal with Carlton anymore, because they felt they were treated badly in the Judd deal. West Coast were obliged to trade Judd to a club of his choice, and Carlton didn't offer a "fair trade" in return.

Answer 4

what lozz said :)

we were treated absolutly patheticly!!

Answer 5

Yes ironical that they didn't want to deal with Collingwood over Judd after the Malthouse defection with year left on his contract and Carlton ended up using that to their full advantage.