Yankees and Mariners fans. If you were the GM of your team, would you make this trade?

Question

Yankees get Washburn and Ibanez for Melky.

Answer 1

no maybe if they have me 2 of they best picters

Answer 2

wtf

h***s no

das not even wats being proposed

its kei igawa for washburn

i dont want washburn

but if das da trade idc  but i dont want to give up anything for washburn becuz we have better pitchers then him

Answer 3

No Washburn is too good of a pitcher to give up for Melky alone, but also with Raul I don't think the Mariners can afford to give that up.

Answer 4

No way. Being a Yankee fan, giving up Melky would be a mistake. They have to hold onto young talent like his.

Answer 5

no way. as a yankees fan, i would say that they should not do that because melky is young and he has talent. we need to keep that