Yankees vs Red Sox. Last game of season. Who do you choose to pinch hit?

Question

It's the top of the 9th, 2 outs. Players on 1st and 2nd. It's 2-0. The Yankees are tied with the Red Sox in the Wild Card. Jonathon Papelbon is the closer but he has allowed a walk and a single and two strike outs. Robinson Cano is about to bat. He is 0-for-4 with 4 K's. You decide to call a pinch hitter. There are three on the bench: A-Rod, Jeter, and Nady. Who do you choose to pinch hit and why?

Answer 1

Bucky Dent

Answer 2

Why did A Rod, Jeter, and Nady sit out the most important game of the season?

Answer 3

A-rod. because he will strike out and the red sox will win

Answer 4

Even if Robinson were 0-4 I doubt they'd pinch hit for him. ARod would all ready be in the game, so would Jeter, and that leaves Nady who could be left to pinch hit so I guess him.

For some fantasy odd question of yours no matter the situation Jeter is Mr Clutch and would always be picked, but like I said he'd all ready be in the game.

Answer 5

A-Rod needs to talk to Angels closer Francisco Rodriguez and work out a deal to steal Franscisco's nickname.  K-Rod fits Alex Rodriguez better than A-Rod these days.

Give me Jeter BTW.  1 Clutch hitter vs. 1 definitely "not clutch" and 1 "I don't know if he's clutch" hitter.

Answer 6

Obviously, that situation would never happen, but if it did, I would have to go with Jeter, though it's a tough call between those 3. Nady's been clutch, and I just want to see how A-Rod would handle that. I'd use Damon over any of those three, though. He'd just go deep around Pesky's Pole to put us up 3-2, and then Enter Sandman. Sleep with one eye open, BoSox.