Your top 5 most underrated and overrated in the NHL:?

Question

In this particular order:

Underrated=

1. Sergei Gonchar

2. Olli Jokinen

3. Rick Nash

4. Marek Svatos

5. Sean Avery

Notable Mention: Marc Savard

Overrated=

1. Jordan Staal

2. Sergei Federov

3. Ryan Malone

4. Chris Osgood

5. Jonathan Cheechoo

Notable Mention: Jose Theodore

Answer 1

Underated:

1.Sergei Gonchar

2. Mike Knuble

3.Rj Umbereger

4.Thomas Vanek

5. Marin St.Louis

OVerated

1. Chris osgood

2.Jordan Staal

3. Marin Hossa

4. Danny Brierre

5. Jay pandolfo

Answer 2

I don't think anybody would overrate Sergei Fedorov.  I would have also said the same thing about Jose Theodore if not for his performance down the stretch last year.

I like your under-rated list, except for Gonchar.  Savard is an excellent choice.  I don't have 5 of each, but here's my list:

Underrated:

Brad Boyes

Jason Pominville

Marc Savard

Overrated:

Markus Naslund

Mats Sundin

Marian Hossa

Answer 3

underrated=

1.rod brind'amore

2. cam ward

3. manny legace

4. martin st louis

5. adam foote

overrated=

1. tie domi

2. joran staal

3. nikolai khabibulin

4. vincent lecavalier

5. bobby holik

Answer 4

I'm not even sure if I'd consider Gonch underrated anymore, because he's talked about being underrated so much!

s***w ratings! =)

But how you can call Sergei Fedorov overrated baffles me...

Answer 5

Underrated -

1. Sergei Gonchar (he get's snubbed all the time)

2. Andrei Kostitsyn

3. Maxime Talbot

4. Kristopher Letang

5. Mark Streit

Overrated -

1. Daniel Alfredson

2. Marian Hossa

3. Ryan Miller

4. Jonathan Cheechoo

5. Daniel Briere

Answer 6

Underrated

1. Marc Savard

2. Derek Roy

3. Anze Kopitar

4. Pierre-Marc Bouchard

5. Ray Whitney

Goalies

1. Giguere

2. Backstrom

3. Thomas

Overrated

1. Jason Spezza

2. Marian Gaborik (until he can go without an injury)

3. Sedin's

4. Daniel Briere

5. Jason Blake

Goalies

1. Theodore

2. Khabibulin

3. Luongo

Answer 7

underrated

rick nash

sean avery

overrated

ryan smith

jamir jagar

thats all i got

Answer 8

Underrated:

1. Segei Gonchar

2. Marc Savard

3. Rick Nash

4. Martin St. Louis

5. Olli Jokinen

Overrated:

1. Tim Thomas

2. Chris Osgood

3. Daniel Briere

4. Carey Price

5. Jonathon Cheechoo

Tim Thomas suucks..I saw somebody said he was underrated. No, he is not. Worst fundamental goalie in the league...this is coming from a Bruins fan.

Answer 9

Underrated

1. Antoine Vermette

2. Rick Nash

3. Olli Jokinen

4. Marc Savard

5. Rod Brind'Amour

I agree on all of the overrated