"If were not supposed to eat chickens, cows and pigs why are they made of meat?"?

Question

A person arguing against animal rights just said that to me, I was so disturbed by a lack of logical thought i had to end the conversation.

Now is it me or is that among the dumbest statements ever?

If were not supposed to eat human babies why are they made of meat?

Answer 1

Ignorance is bliss isn't it?

Answer 2

we are what we eat as the saying goes believe it or not it does...eat just anything but not meat doesn't that sounds like a sheep in the field,eat just meat and you end up with stripes of yellow and black or big beard behind a cage in a zoo somewhere and becoming extinct...eat fairly of any food group and you end up as human as can be...see it cater different needs for different part of your body....why do people like those even exists...

Answer 3

Perhaps the person was trying to needle you into a foolish reaction.

There are no end of people with illogical beliefs.  Please try to not let them push your buttons  so that you behave as illogically and foolishly as they do.

From the answers already, you must know that you have support for what you think, which I hope is a comfort to you.

Answer 4

Yes that is a very dumb, illogical statement. I wouldn't take it seriously if I were you.  

Answer 5

Going by that statement's logic, we should eat each other, considering humans are made up of flesh too (among other things like bone).

Dumb: ''If animals were not made to be eaten, why are they made out of meat?''

Dumber: ''You need meat'' or ''If you don't eat meat, WHAT do you eat?!''

Dumbest: ''If we didn't eat animals they would overpopulate and take over the world...''

I've heard practically all of the anti vegetarian arguments and they all get tiresome after a while. Sigh..

Answer 6

humans are made of meat too. do you eat them?

Answer 7

i think he was trying to get under your skin...it worked

Answer 8

Thats Friggin Dumb

Its Called Flesh

Your Right Mate

Godh I hate Stupid People

xoxo

Answer 9

Well, the Bible says that it is OK for us to eat meat and God is the creator of our bodies and knows how they work and what they need.  If I want to know the right thing to do for my car I consult the owner's manual which was written by the people who created the car.  If I want to know what is good for my body I consult the Bible which is the owner's manual from the one who created my body.

Answer 10

It maybe dumb...

But honestly its one of the funniest things I have heard in a long time.

Perhaps they were just pulling your chain?

Answer 11

whoever said that is a r****d and just because something is edible doesnt mean its right to eat ur right dat dude was a dumb***

Answer 12

in matters of life or death: if a human were starving to death and the only food available was the flesh of a dead human being, that would be the best food source possible. every single component needed for a human being to survive, is another human being. this is a logical statement. but it is not an ethical statement.

some of the strongest, biggest, fastest animals on the planet are vegeterians! i.e.horses.-blurey

Answer 13

i'm told  trolls taste like chicken... (so they kept telling me)..  but later i only found them to taste like c**p.